🍕 Best Italian & Pizza in New York City
248 italian & pizza spots in New York City, scored and ranked for 2026.
🍽️ Open Interactive GuideTop 10 Italian & Pizza Spots
1
Carbone
The most theatrical Italian restaurant in America. The tuxedoed waiters, the Sinatra soundtrack, the spicy rigatoni vodka that launched a thousand Instagram reels — Carbone is dinner as performance ar...
99
2
Via Carota
The most impossible walk-in in New York. Jody Williams and Rita Sodi's West Village Italian has been packed to the rafters for a decade, and the cacio e pepe still makes grown adults weep. Seasonal ve...
99
3
Lilia
Missy Robbins turned a Williamsburg warehouse into one of the five best Italian restaurants in America. The mafaldini with pink peppercorn is the dish that put her on the map, and the agnolotti will h...
99
4
Don Angie
Don Angie took the red-sauce Italian joint and turned it inside out. The pinwheel lasagna is an architectural marvel, the chrysanthemum bread is absurdly good, and the cherry pepper rigatoni could con...
99
5
I Sodi
Rita Sodi's tiny West Village Italian has 30 seats, zero pretension, and pasta that will make you reconsider everything you thought you knew about Italian food. The cacio e pepe is the definitive vers...
96
6
Dante
Voted World's Best Bar in 2019, and the negroni menu alone justifies the title. Dante transformed from a century-old Italian cafe into the cocktail epicenter of Greenwich Village without losing an oun...
95
7
Lucali
Mark Iacono's Carroll Gardens pizzeria serves exactly two things: whole pies and calzones. That's it. No slices, no appetizers, BYOB, cash only, and a line that wraps around the block every single nig...
95
8
Torrisi
Rich Torrisi's triumphant return to the kitchen in the landmark Puck Building on Mulberry Street. Italian-American food elevated to Michelin-star levels — the chicken parm, the lobster fra diavolo, an...
95
9
Francie
A Williamsburg brasserie that earned a Michelin star doing everything exactly right. The crown roast of Rohan duck, the shellfish platter, and the butter cake all land. Exposed brick and candlelight g...
93
10
Una Pizza Napoletana
Anthony Mangieri's pizza temple on the Lower East Side where each pie is a masterclass in simplicity and obsessive craftsmanship. He makes a limited number of pizzas each day with meticulously sourced...
93
All 248 Italian & Pizza Spots in New York City
Rezdôra
93
Marea
92
L'Artusi
91
L'Industrie Pizzeria
91
Ai Fiori
91
Bar Madonna
91
Giulietta
91
Aromi
91
Cremini's
91
Rialto Ristorante
91
Joe's Pizza
90
Rao's
90
Roberta's
90
Misi
90
Scarr's Pizza
90
Ribalta
90
Sungold
90
Bucatini
90
Lulla
90
Bar Mario
90
Bar B
90
Di Fara Pizza
89
Prince Street Pizza
89
Juliana's Pizza
89
Il Buco
89
King
89
Ci Siamo
89
Al Di La Trattoria
89
Jupiter
89
Café Altro Paradiso
89
Massara
89
Zero Otto Nove
88
Rubirosa
88
Rolo's
88
Locanda Verde
88
Charlie Bird
88
Pasquale Jones
88
Raf's
88
Café Carmellini
88
Song' E Napule
88
F&F Pizzeria
88
Scarpetta
88
Il Mulino New York
88
San Sabino
88
Carne Mare
88
I Cavallini
88
Da Toscano
88
Santi
88
Park Side
88
Sullivan Street Bakery
88
Bar Americano
88
Stretch Pizza
88
Audace
88
Carmenta's
88
Lucky Charlie
88
Water & Wheat
88
Cucina Italian Tavern
88
Evelina
88
LaRina Pastificio & Vino
88
La Voglia NYC
88
72nd Eatery
88
La Bomboniera
88
Daphne's
88
Wayward Fare
88
Alidoro
87
Babbo
87
Roscioli NYC
87
Borgo
87
Motorino
87
Kimika
87
Gjelina
87
Barlume
87
Cucina Alba
87
Scalinatella
87
Roman's
87
ZZ's Club New York
87
Pizza Secret
87
Fiaschetteria Pistoia
87
Saraghina
86
Veniero's Pasticceria
86
Emmy Squared
86
Bad Roman
86
Morandi
86
Cecconi's Dumbo
86
Roberto's
86
Mama's Too
86
Barbuto
86
Sant Ambroeus
86
Faicco's Italian Specialties
86
Upside Pizza
86
Kesté
86
Forsythia
86
Osteria Morini
86
Cafe Mars
86
Leuca
86
Leon's
86
Upland
86
Da Umberto
86
Locanda Vini e Olii
86
Noodle Pudding
86
Caffe Reggio
86
Uncle Peter's
86
Armondo's Italian Restaurant
86
Milkflower
86
Bread And Salt
86
Laico's
86
Palma
86
Barolo East
86
Sesamo
86
Terre
86
Barbalu
86
Mariella
86
314
86
Turbo Pizza
85
Il Leone
85
Emily
85
Enoteca Maria
85
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana
85
Frankies 457 Spuntino
85
Paulie Gee's
85
Leo
85
Hearth
85
Emilio's Ballato
85
Quality Italian
85
Mike's Deli at Arthur Avenue
85
OLIO e PIU
85
Lioni Italian Heroes
85
Pisillo Italian Panini
85
All'Antico Vinaio
85
Aqua
85
The Ned NoMad
85
Andrew Bellucci's Pizzeria
85
Salsa
85
Soda Club
85
Bar Bianchi
85
Saint Theo's
85
Ace's Pizza
84
Sandro's
84
Lavo Italian Restaurant
84
John's of Bleecker Street
84
Arthur Avenue Retail Market
84
Ops
84
Don Antonio
84
Grimaldi's Pizzeria
84
Joe & Pat's
84
Patsy's Pizzeria
84
Cafe Spaghetti
84
L&B Spumoni Gardens
84
Eataly NYC Flatiron
84
Bar Pisellino
84
Speedy Romeo
84
Casa Della Mozzarella
84
Lombardi's Pizza
84
Denino's Pizzeria
84
Best Pizza
84
NY Pizza Suprema
84
Bar Pitti
84
Sal Kris & Charlie's Deli
84
Parisi Bakery
84
Sauce Pizzeria
84
Bar Rocco
84
Via Quadronno
84
La Pecora Bianca
84
Randazzo's Clam Bar
84
Il Corso
84
Pasticceria Rocco
84
Travelers Poets & Friends
84
Aurora
84
Bamonte's
84
Sotto La Luna
84
Lucia Pizza
84
Jr & Son
84
Vinatería
84
Chrissy's Pizza
84
Razza
84
Sartiano's
84
Bird Dog
84
Lido
84
Toscana 49
84
Pisticci
84
Briciola
84
Aria Wine Bar
84
Pepe Giallo
84
Le Fanfare
84
Fausto
84
Gersi
84
Da Capo
84
Max Soha
84
Black Oak on Fifth
84
Osteria Radisa
84
Mario's
84
Lil' Frankie's
83
Third Time's the Charm
83
Full Moon Pizzeria
83
Williamsburg Pizza
83
Eataly Panini Counter
83
Pietro's
83
Settepani on the Meer
83
Pepe Rosso To Go
82
La Lanterna di Vittorio
82
Corner Slice
82
Artichoke Basille's Pizza
82
Patsy's Italian Restaurant
82
The Palm Too
82
Carmine's Italian Restaurant (Times Square)
82
Dell'Aria
82
Rosetta Bakery
82
Pizza Studio Tamaki
82
Straker's NYC
82
Bocca di Bacco
82
Amarone
82
Pasta Louise
82
Botte Brooklyn
82
Mamo
82
Emporio
82
Panineria
81
Corto
81
Montagu's Gusto
80
Uva
80
Allora
80
Sociale
80
Tartina
80
Tony's Di Napoli (Times Square)
79
Inatteso Cafe
79
2 Bros. Pizza
78
Milano Market (Upper East Side)
78
Milano Market Westside
78
Di Palo's Fine Foods
78
Pisillo Italian Panini (Financial District)
78
Agata & Valentina
78
Agata & Valentina Gluten Free
78
Fermento Pizza
78
Amore Pizzeria
78
15 Fox Place
78
V&T Restaurant & Pizzeria
78
Jet's Pizza
76
Ceres
76
Dollar Slice NYC
75
More New York City Categories
🥞 Brunch
🕯️ Date Night
🍽️ Fine Dining
🔥 BBQ
🍸 Happy Hour
☀️ Patio Dining
🍹 Bars & Cocktails
🌮 Mexican & Tex-Mex
🍣 Sushi & Japanese
😎 Casual Dining
🍺 Breweries & Craft Beer
🥘 Korean
🍜 Vietnamese
🍝 Ramen & Noodles
🫓 Indian
🌿 Thai
🦞 Seafood
🌮 Tacos
🥦 Vegan & Plant-Based
☕ Coffee & Cafés
🥩 Steakhouses
🌆 Rooftop & Views
🥟 Chinese & Dim Sum
🍰 Desserts & Bakeries
Italian & Pizza in Other Cities
Dallas
Houston
Austin
Chicago
Salt Lake City
Seattle
Las Vegas
Los Angeles
Miami
Charlotte
San Francisco
San Antonio
Nashville
Phoenix
San Diego
Toronto
DC
Mexico City
New Orleans
Dim Hour scores the best restaurants across America. Full guide → · All New York City restaurants →