📍 Coney Island / South Brooklyn, New York City
10 restaurants · 2026
🍽️ 10 Restaurants
Old-school New York pizza — coal-fired and square-slice both — alongside a Lebanese kitchen and the Stillwell Avenue boardwalk.
Top 10 in Coney Island / South Brooklyn
1
Di Fara Pizza
Dom DeMarco made every single pie by hand at his Midwood pizzeria for over 50 years. He's gone now, but his family carries on, and the regular slice — charred, oily, dripping with ...
89
2
Tanoreen
Rawia Bishara's Bay Ridge Palestinian restaurant is one of the most celebrated Middle Eastern restaurants in the five boroughs. The mussakhan is extraordinary — roasted chicken wit...
86
3
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana
Operating since 1924, Totonno is one of New York true pizza legends -- a no-frills Coney Island institution charring pies in the same coal-fired oven for a century. The pizza is ma...
85
4
Lioni Italian Heroes
Bensonhurst Italian hero shop that ships nationwide because people who move away from Brooklyn literally cannot live without these sandwiches. The house-made mozzarella is the foun...
85
5
L&B Spumoni Gardens
Brooklyn institution since 1939 famous for the Sicilian square slice — sauce on top, cheese on bottom — that's unlike any other pizza in the city. The crust is thick, crispy, and s...
84
6
Coney Island
NYC's original beachfront amusement district with Luna Park rides, the 1927 Cyclone roller coaster, Nathan's hot dogs, the boardwalk, and the New York Aquarium. The Cyclone is a wo...
84
7
Purple Yam
Amy Besa and Romy Dorotan's pan-Southeast Asian restaurant in Ditmas Park with a focus on Filipino cooking. The kare-kare, sisig, and ube desserts all shine. A pioneering Filipino ...
84
8
La Cabañita
Sunset Park taqueria on 5th Avenue's Mexican restaurant row serving authentic tacos, cemitas, and fresh aguas frescas at prices that make the trip to Brooklyn's Latin quarter worth...
83
9
Pho Hoai
Williamsburg pho shop with rich, deeply flavorful beef broth and portions generous enough to get you through a Brooklyn winter. No-frills setting, honest cooking, and a bowl of pho...
82
10
Nathan's Famous
The original 1916 Coney Island hot dog stand that spawned an empire and an annual Fourth of July eating contest that has become as American as the hot dogs themselves. The snap of ...
82
More New York City Neighborhoods
📍 Midtown West
📍 Flatiron / NoMad
📍 Williamsburg
📍 Greenwich Village
📍 West Village
📍 SoHo
📍 Lower East Side
📍 Financial District
📍 Greenpoint
📍 Chelsea
📍 Brooklyn Heights
📍 Carroll Gardens / Cobble Hill
Dim Hour scores the best restaurants across America. Full guide → · All New York City restaurants →