← All San Diego Restaurants

📍 Shelter Island, San Diego

3 restaurants · 2026

🍽️ 3 Restaurants

A short causeway to marina dining rooms, a Polynesian tiki landmark, and seafood with postcard views back toward the downtown skyline

🍽️ Open Interactive Guide

Top 3 in Shelter Island

1
Fathom Bistro, Bait & Tackle
American / Seafood / Bar
Shelter Island's pier-end bait-shop-and-bistro — a working-pier format with a craft-beer bar, a fishing tackle shop attached, and a patio that runs right to the Shelter Island bay....
84
2
Humphreys by the Bay
American / Seafood
Humphreys by the Bay on Shelter Island Drive is a dining room and a concert-series venue in one — bayfront views over Shelter Island harbor, a seafood-forward American menu, and a ...
83
3
Bali Hai Restaurant
Polynesian / Pacific Rim
Historic Shelter Island tiki temple operating since 1954, known for panoramic San Diego bay and downtown skyline views, Polynesian artifacts, and the 'world's strongest' Mai Tais —...
80
🍽️ Explore Full San Diego Guide
Patio (3) Casual (3) American (2) Seafood (2) Scenic Views (2) Date Night (2) Iconic (2) Bar (1) Local Favorites (1) Hidden Gem (1) Happy Hour (1) Celebrations (1)

More San Diego Neighborhoods

📍 Carlsbad 📍 University Heights 📍 Solana Beach 📍 Little Italy 📍 Del Mar 📍 Gaslamp 📍 East Village 📍 Downtown 📍 La Jolla 📍 North Park 📍 Bankers Hill 📍 South Park

Dim Hour scores the best restaurants across America. Full guide → · All San Diego restaurants →